💥 Reach thousands of inboxes in minutes: All new 'Email Campaigns' is here! - Learn More

Book 35% more follow-up sales calls: 7 tips that really work!

For sales reps, one of the most gratifying feelings is getting a prospect on a call after weeks (sometimes even months) of chasing. 

However, if you’ve worked in sales long enough, you know by now not to get too excited. 

Statistics show that 80% of sales require 5 follow-up calls to close. The first time you interact with a buyer is really only the beginning of a much longer sales process. To get to the finish line, you must first master the art of follow-up.

At Salesmate, we tried these tips and ended up booking 35% more sales follow-up calls!

Tips for scheduling follow-up sales calls

The work you put in during the initial sales conversations with a buyer is crucial to building the foundation for a mutually-beneficial relationship, with the hopes of ultimately closing the deal further down the line.

Getting a prospect to commit to a follow-up call can be just as difficult as catching them cold for the first time. 

To add insult to injury, a lot can go wrong between sales conversations that could jeopardize your follow-up meeting. The buyer has time to consider your product, consider if it’s worth pursuing, or even lose interest altogether.

At the end of the day, you can’t control whether or not they show up, but there are a few surefire steps you can take beforehand to increase the chances that they stick around. 

Let’s get started.

Take detailed notes during the first call

While it’s true that a prospect should have your full attention during a call, you should still take notes to make sure you don’t miss any important details.

What you learn from the first conversation will shape your selling strategy moving forward, so it’s crucial to jot down as much relevant information as possible.

All the work that went into running the first discovery call can go out the window if you have no way of remembering what was said afterward.

Many modern sales teams rely on conversation intelligence software to record calls automatically, but an old fashioned pencil and paper can still be just as useful if you’re an efficient note-taker. All that matters is that your notes are detailed enough to guide you moving forward.

Take notes while talking to your prospects

Take notes while talking to your prospects

Salesmate empowers you to take notes while you're on call and add them to Contact timeline!

Explore Built-in Calling

Gauge interest

Walking away from a potential deal is never easy. However, it’s sometimes necessary not to move forward with a prospect if you realize that your product or service does not fit their needs.

By asking the right questions, you can gauge the prospect’s interest and decide whether the next steps will even be necessary. If they show a clear disinterest in what you’re selling, then it’s OK not to schedule a follow-up call.

Sometimes, it’s just not a good fit. Although it might be hard to walk away from a potential sale, it’s best to do so in the beginning stages of the sales cycle. You’re saving yourself time in the long run by avoiding a deal that will likely fall through anyway.

Outline clear and actionable next steps

As a salesperson, it’s your job to own the conversation and outline clear expectations for the next steps. During the initial call, lock down a date and time to re-connect while you still have everyone’s attention.

Ensure you get verbal confirmation that the agreed-upon day and time work well with their schedule. Tell them you will follow up with a calendar invite, so they know to expect a digital placeholder from you.

Additionally, be sure to briefly let them know what you plan to cover during the follow-up conversation. If it’s not apparent to them that another call is necessary, they may push back on your request. Be concise and explain exactly why another call is beneficial and what they will gain from agreeing to meet with you again.

Send a follow-up email summarizing your conversation
Following the end of the first sales call with a prospect, the immediate next step is to send them an email recap.

This is where the notes we discussed earlier come in handy. The goal is to briefly summarize your conversation, highlight the main takeaways, and re-iterate any next steps you discussed.

The keyword here is brief – no one wants to read a giant block of text in an email, especially right after a long sales call. Here’s an example:

A follow-up email serves as a reminder of the meaningful conversation you already had and will give the prospective buyer an idea of what to expect on the next call.

You can even create an email template where you fill in the details of the previous call. Encourage them to come prepared to the next meeting with questions or concerns, allowing for a productive conversation.

Avoid “touching base” for no reason

It may be tempting to contact the buyer between calls to stay top-of-mind, but this can backfire if your outreach comes off as annoying or unnecessary. Resist the urge to “check in” or “touch base” without providing value. 

For example, you can try engaging with your prospect on social media. This can be as simple as liking a shared tweet or tagging them in a relevant LinkedIn post.

A social media interaction is an effective and much less-intrusive way of staying on their radar. This is also a perfect time to review your notes and identify opportunities for providing additional value.

What are their main objections? What problems are they looking to solve? Send them a helpful piece of content that addresses their concerns head-on or point them to a third-party review site and let your customers speak for themselves.

Your message should lead with copy that indicates you remember your last conversation:

With this approach, your outreach comes off as consultative instead of sales-y.

Send email reminders

Always be sure to send a reminder at least 24 hours before your scheduled meeting. This is a simple way to give a nudge without being overly aggressive in your approach.

People are busy, and your sales call isn’t going to be top-of-mind for them during a hectic work week. Sending a quick email with the calendar invite is a simple way to remind them of your upcoming meeting.

It also allows the buyer to reschedule if they realize that they have a conflict. Re-scheduling isn’t ideal, but it’s much better than a no-show. Many sales reps use calendar software to stay organized and keep track of upcoming reminders.

Why spend extra on meeting scheduling software?

Why spend extra on meeting scheduling software?

Manage prospects, deals, meetings from Salesmate CRM.

Explore Meeting Scheduler

Be persistent

Getting ghosted by prospects is a harsh reality of working in sales. No matter how hard you try, it’s more than likely that there will be times when someone just doesn’t show up for a call and stops responding to your messages.

When faced with a prospect going dark, it’s important to remember that this doesn’t mean the deal is dead.

Persistence is key to an effective follow-up strategy. Try not to let yourself get discouraged by no-shows.

There’s always a reason why a buyer didn’t show up but don’t assume it’s because they’re not interested. Instead, assume they had another meeting or simply forgot.

Hey, it happens!

Follow up with them until you get a response. If you still don’t hear anything after several attempts, it’s a good idea to stop reaching out.

There’s a fine line between being persistent and being pushy – finding a balance between the two is an essential sales skill.

Following up manually can be tedious, and that’s the exact spot where automation can help your business.

You can design a series of emails and set them on auto-pilot. We call it sales email sequence or sales cadence. A series of well-planted emails will be sent according to your conditions. You can set up a specific time and template for each email and set the gap between two emails.

This is why Salesmate can be a tremendous choice for your business. Salesmate lets you create automatic email sequences that you wish, based on your rules and conditions!

Be persitent the smarter way!

Be persitent the smarter way!

Automate sales follow-up emails using Sequences and invest your time on selling!

Explore Email Sequences

Concluding thoughts

Asking for a prospective buyer’s time is never easy, especially early on in the sales process when you have yet to establish rapport.

Remember these tips next time you’re booking a follow-up call, and remember that providing meaningful value should be at the center of your sales efforts.

The more value you communicate early on, the more likely a prospect will stick around and eventually become a customer.


Izabelle is a Content Marketing Associate at G2, a B2B review marketplace for software and services. She specializes in sales, marketing, and real estate content. After earning a degree in Journalism from the University of Missouri, Izabelle moved back to her hometown of Chicago, where she currently resides.

You may also enjoy these

Sales follow up: 7 Tried & tested strategies [8 templates inside] 

Sales follow up is a process that salespeople use to reconnect with potential clients after their initial meeting...

27 Min read
How to use sales battle card to boost win rates (Templates)

Claiming you're unmatched doesn't always seal the...

17 Min read
10 Best sales management tools that you must check in 2024!

A sales management software solution designed to manage and optimize the sales process, from lead management to...

21 Min read
Value-based selling: Transforming customer needs into sales

In a survey by ValueSelling Associates Inc., it was found that 87% of high-growth companies use a value-based...

21 Min read
Discovery meeting: How to do it successfully? [Free template]

Imagine stepping onto the stage, the spotlight hits, and the audience waits with bated breath. This is your...

19 Min read

Make sales sexy again 😉

  • Save at least 50% on subscriptions and integrations.
  • Save 30% more time for your sales team.
  • Choose a CRM trusted by 5000+ businesses.
salesmate CRM
Scroll to Top
Scroll to Top